8.4

Vineyard Golf Club

Course info

ACCESS
Private
EST.
2002
GRASS
Bentgrass
SEASON
April–October
CART TYPE
Not Allowed
avg. Price
$
350
?
CADDIES
Unknown
Type
Parkland
Unknown
Par
72
Unknown
Holes
18
Stimpmeter
10.5
City
Edgartown

Score

8.4
Design
40%
8.6
Conditions
25%
8.8
Desirability
15%
7.8
Scenery
10%
8.1
Fun
5%
7.8
Uniqueness
5%
8.0

Difficulty

Overall
Hard

Slope 131

75
155

Scratch Rating

-10
0
+10

Stimpmeter 10.5

7
15

Walkability Easy

Easy
Brutal

Weather

Average Rain Medium

Low
Extreme

Average Wind Medium

Low
Extreme

Price

?
?
?
$
300
$
350
$
400
Low
Average
High

Yearly Rounds

0
75,000

Course Report

Vineyard Golf Club is the first course in the country to be maintained 100% organically, making it a pioneer in sustainable golf course management.

About

Vineyard Golf Club, designed by Gil Hanse and Jim Wagner, is renowned as the first fully organic golf course in the United States. Stretching 7,100 yards, this private club on Martha’s Vineyard features classic architecture, pristine natural beauty, and a caddie program recognized as one of the best in the Northeast. Strictly walking-only and member-exclusive, its playability and conditioning are elite.

Caddie Tip

Pay close attention to wind direction, as conditions change quickly on Martha’s Vineyard and the course was designed to put the breeze in play. Trust your caddie’s advice, especially on approach angles and club selection, as reading the organic fairways and fast, undulating greens requires precise planning. Patience and smart shot placement are rewarded here.

The Main Challenge

The toughest aspect of Vineyard Golf Club is its demanding approach play. Greens are well-protected by strategic bunkers and native grasses, requiring thoughtful shot placement and distance control. Wind patterns can shift quickly, making club selection vital. The walk-only layout also requires stamina and precise course management to post a competitive score.

The Good

Golfers most love the pristine course conditions and tranquil atmosphere created by the organic maintenance practices and natural setting. The caddie program is highly praised, offering expert guidance and enhancing the walking-only experience. Architectural purists appreciate Hanse’s commitment to strategic design, blending classic influences with Martha’s Vineyard’s native terrain.

The Not So Good

Some players desire greater year-round accessibility, as the April–October season can make it difficult to secure tee times in peak months. As a private, walking-only club, some guests have noted that the exclusivity and caddie requirements, while beneficial for preservation and experience, can make access and flexibility less convenient for visitors.

Signature Hole:

#

13

No items found.

The 13th hole, a memorable par 3, plays across a natural sand hazard to a well-protected green bordered by native grasses. Precision is essential to avoid the deep bunkers around the putting surface, while the ocean breeze and undulating contours can add to the drama. It’s a visual highlight, showcasing the club’s commitment to organic, naturalistic design.

Clubhouse

The elegant clubhouse offers upscale locker rooms, a well-appointed dining area featuring fresh local cuisine, and relaxed lounge spaces. Member-focused service is emphasized, and outside guests are rare. Additional amenities include club storage, showers, and a pro shop tailored to a luxury private setting.

Practice Facilities

No items found.

Vineyard Golf Club offers high-quality, all-organic practice facilities including a full driving range, short game area, and putting greens. Instruction is available from experienced professionals and the caddie program provides on-course coaching. The facilities maintain the club’s organic approach, ensuring superb but environmentally invested practice conditions.

Dress Code:

Prestigious

No dress code enforced. All attire is permitted.

Collared shirts not required. Clean, athletic or golf-appropriate casual wear is acceptable.

Collared shirts required. No denim, gym wear, or overly casual clothing.

Collared shirts must be tucked in; no cargo or athletic shorts. No hats indoors.

Elite club standards; jackets required indoors, no changing shoes in the parking lot, and specific attire rules based on the area of the facility.

Massachusetts
U.S.A.