ARCHITECTS
Course info
Score
Difficulty
Weather
Price
Course Report
Garden City Golf Club is one of the last remaining men-only golf clubs in the United States and has hosted the U.S. Open as well as multiple U.S. Amateur championships.
About
Garden City Golf Club is an elite men-only private club founded in 1899 in Garden City, NY. Originally designed by Devereux Emmet and later updated by Walter Travis, the course is known for its strategic design, deep pot bunkers, fescue rough, and fast-running fairways. The club has hosted major championships, including the U.S. Open and several U.S. Amateurs.
Caddie Tip
Manage your game conservatively and respect the bunkering: focus on placement rather than length, especially off the tee. The fescue rough and deep pot bunkers can penalize overly aggressive shots, so study pin positions carefully and use the ground game where possible to avoid tricky recoveries.
The Main Challenge
The greatest challenge lies in navigating the numerous strategically placed bunkers and thick fescue rough. Firm and fast conditions reward good shot-shaping and thoughtful course management, while the ever-changing wind can turn every hole into a fresh test.
The Good
Members and guests praise the course for its timeless strategy, fast and firm links-style conditions, and the unique challenge presented by its deep bunkering and ever-present winds. The quiet, historic vibe, exclusivity, and lack of modern distractions make Garden City one of the country’s purest golf experiences.
The Not So Good
The course’s relentless difficulty and challenging bunkers can frustrate less-skilled golfers, and its exclusive men-only policy is a regular target of criticism. Some also wish the club would modernize certain amenities or consider allowing limited outside play.
Signature Hole:
#
2
The 2nd hole, a par 4, is the club’s most iconic. It demands a strategic tee shot through a corridor flanked by thick fescue and deep bunkering, requiring accuracy over brute strength. The approach plays to a well-defended green, making par a significant accomplishment, especially if the wind is up.
Clubhouse
The historic clubhouse offers a classic, understated environment with locker rooms, dining spaces, and a patio overlooking the course. The amenities are designed for comfort and tradition rather than flash, reflecting the club’s no-frills, golf-first philosophy.
Practice Facilities
Garden City features a traditional driving range and short game area for members to hone their game. Facilities are understated but well-maintained, focusing on core practice needs rather than resort-style luxury.
Dress Code:
Prestigious
No dress code enforced. All attire is permitted.
Collared shirts not required. Clean, athletic or golf-appropriate casual wear is acceptable.
Collared shirts required. No denim, gym wear, or overly casual clothing.
Collared shirts must be tucked in; no cargo or athletic shorts. No hats indoors.
Elite club standards; jackets required indoors, no changing shoes in the parking lot, and specific attire rules based on the area of the facility.
.avif)
.png)
.png)
